Gifts for Mystery Lovers - Puzzling and Literary Items

Unravel the excitement with this collection of gifts for mystery lovers! From secret message pens to detective-themed puzzles, this assortment is sure to keep them on their toes. Perfect for those who love a good whodunit and a dash of intrigue!

Christmas Mystery Advent Calendar$50.00
not yet rated
Back in StockMurdle Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle$20.00
4.6 stars out of 5 16
Murder Mystery Puzzle Book$19.00
4.7 stars out of 5 128
New!Color & Solve Murder Mystery Mansion Book$16.00
not yet rated
featured customer reviews
5 stars out of 5
Perfect for those who like a little mystery in their life
Great gift for my friend who loves all things puzzle and mystery! Cute packaging, fun to solve! Will be buying the other stories!
Jj
Parsippany, NJ
Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle
$20.00
5 stars out of 5
Great Gift for the Super Sleuth
This is a quality item with all the details thought out. My sister loves it! She read aloud all about it when she opened her gift. Definitely an uncommon and perfect gift for her!
Carrot59
San Angelo, Texas
Murdle Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle
$20.00
5 stars out of 5
Creative, unique, and fun
My friend loves puzzles and murder mystery games, so this gift was perfect for her. She especially loved the cool art throughout the book.
Jay
Colorado
Murder Mystery Puzzle Book
$19.00
5 stars out of 5
Great gift for amateur sleuths
I purchased this for a relative who loves to watch true crime, listen to podcasts, and solve mysteries. This gives him enjoy solving mysteries in a new way!
Amateur Sleuth
Noblesville, IN
Murdle Detective Puzzle Book
$18.00
5 stars out of 5
The perfect gift for puzzler and mystery lover
My mom loves puzzles and mystery novels. I've already got her a few of those other mystery novel puzzles but who resist a puzzle based on the reigning queen of mystery! I love that we get to do these together.
LR
Ontario, Canada
Spot the Hidden Clues Agatha Christie Puzzle
$25.00
5 stars out of 5
A dream gift for a want to be sleuth
My daughter in law and son are so into true crime and detective shows and work. They are both 28 years old and sometimes it is hard to buy for their age and especially when they buy everything they want and need. They live very minimalist so experience is key. This is a great gift and not too easy. Fun and great for couples!
Just jeni
Temecula, California
Madok's Interactive Treasure Hunt
$45.00
3 Left!Lattes & Lies: 24 Letter Mystery Subscription$149.00
not yet rated
New!Dickens' Dilemma: Christmas Mystery Game$17.00
not yet rated
Back in StockMurdle Detective Puzzle Book$18.00
4.3 stars out of 5 6
The Ultimate Agatha Christie Puzzle Book$22.00
5 stars out of 5 3
Cranberry Creek Cozy Mystery Word Search Book$15.00
5 stars out of 5 1
Kids First Agatha Christie Mystery Puzzle Book$19.00
3.7 stars out of 5 3
Back in StockMerry Murdle Detective Puzzle Book$16.00
not yet rated
SubscriptionScience Lovers Mystery Box Subscription$135.00 - $255.00
4.8 stars out of 5 8
Back in Stock80's Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle: Dognapped!$20.00
not yet rated
Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle$20.00
4.6 stars out of 5 268
Jane Austen's Plight – Escape Room Game$17.00
5 stars out of 5 2
Pop-Up Mystery Escape Room Game$80.00
5 stars out of 5 3
Unlock the Wine Escape Room Game$30.00
4.1 stars out of 5 54
Kids First Nancy Drew Mystery Puzzle Book$19.00
not yet rated
New!Christmas Cozy Mystery Word Search Book$16.00
not yet rated
5 Minute Mystery Solo or Collaborative Game$35.00
not yet rated
New!Christmas Mystery Chapter-a-Day Advent Book$17.00
not yet rated
The Ghost in the Machine Murder Mystery Game$45.00
not yet rated
Unlock the Whiskey Escape Room$30.00
4.1 stars out of 5 40
Movie Lovers Puzzle Book$20.00
5 stars out of 5 4
Low StockA Blind Date with A Book$19.00
3.8 stars out of 5 10
Search & Find Detective Murder Mystery Game$35.00
not yet rated
Mystery Tarot Blind Box Candle$40.00
5 stars out of 5 1
The Book Lover’s Reading Challenge$30.00
4.9 stars out of 5 15
Master Theorem Book of Puzzles$30.00
4.9 stars out of 5 68
Curious Correspondence: Puzzle Escape Room Games$40.00
not yet rated
Back in StockSpot the Hidden Clues Agatha Christie Puzzle$25.00
4.9 stars out of 5 19
Death for Dinner Horror Movie Cookbook$25.00
5 stars out of 5 7
Codex Regenesis: Immersive Riddle Fables$40.00
not yet rated
Back in StockBook Lover's Tea Collection Gift Box$48.00
4.9 stars out of 5 19
The FairyTale Files Interactive Murder Mysteries$44.00
5 stars out of 5 10
Interactive Literary Classics with Ephemera$40.00 - $43.00
5 stars out of 5 3
Banned Books Puzzle & Reading Checklist$20.00
5 stars out of 5 17
New!My Favorite Book Keepsake Necklace$75.00
not yet rated
Back in Stock100 Movies Scratch Off Bucket List Book$30.00
4.4 stars out of 5 8
Victorian Era Detective Game$35.00
5 stars out of 5 7
The Book Lover's Advent Calendar$30.00
4.2 stars out of 5 18
Scarlet Envelope Murder Mystery Game$25.00
5 stars out of 5 4
Book Lovers Beaded Ornament$20.00
5 stars out of 5 2
The Book Lover's Oracle Deck$22.00
5 stars out of 5 2
Cryptic Circus 3D Pop-Up Escape Room$25.00
not yet rated
Locked Journal with Invisible Ink Pen$19.00
5 stars out of 5 2
New!New York Times Premium Connections Puzzle Book$30.00
not yet rated
Back in Stock100 Horror Movies Scratch Off Chart$25.00
4.8 stars out of 5 8
DIY Dream Library Bookend Kit$40.00
4.8 stars out of 5 4
Classic Literature Mug$18.00
not yet rated
Killer Cocktails Inspired by Historical Crimes$29.00
5 stars out of 5 2
Kids Search & Find Detective Game$30.00
not yet rated
Ultimate Movie-Lovers Fill-In Poster$40.00
4.9 stars out of 5 7
Spot The Hidden Clues Sherlock Holmes Puzzle$25.00
5 stars out of 5 7
Sleeping Cat Secret Storage Box$33.00
4 stars out of 5 3
Jane Austen Escape Room Book$25.00
5 stars out of 5 2
Abandoned Game Factory Mystery Puzzletale$39.00
5 stars out of 5 2
New!For the Love of French Cheese Puzzle$59.00
not yet rated
Library Lovers Candle$24.00
5 stars out of 5 3
New!Seven Courts of the Faerie Realm Puzzle$22.00
not yet rated
Madok's Interactive Treasure Hunt$45.00
4.7 stars out of 5 37
New!Bonding Over Books: Book Club Conversation Cards$25.00
not yet rated
National Parks History By Mail$48.00 - $82.00
5 stars out of 5 6
ExperienceYour Love Story Mapmaking Class$110.00
4.9 stars out of 5 106
Urban Legends By Mail$48.00 - $82.00
4.5 stars out of 5 2
First Edition Book Cover Art Print$65.00
4.7 stars out of 5 40
Entertaining Wizards, Warriors, and Dragons$18.00 - $23.00
3 stars out of 5 1
Book Lover’s Guided Reading Journal$24.00
5 stars out of 5 1
100 Essential Novels Scratch Off Chart$25.00
3.7 stars out of 5 3
Periodic Table of Wine Puzzle$59.00
3.8 stars out of 5 4
Book Tunnel DIY Bookend Kit$38.00
5 stars out of 5 2
A Spot of Divination Tea Leaf Reading Set$30.00
not yet rated
Literary Women Book Locket Necklace$58.00
4 stars out of 5 2
Choose Your Era Escape Room Puzzle Game$20.00
not yet rated
Romantasy Candle$35.00
not yet rated
Back in StockLegends of the National Parks$35.00
4.7 stars out of 5 18
CustomizablePersonalized Secret Diary Book Locket$58.00
not yet rated
How To Speak Cat Cards$10.00
4.9 stars out of 5 38
Guess the Pet Tabletop Game$30.00
5 stars out of 5 1
Meow-ji Board Catnip Kitty Playmat$35.00
5 stars out of 5 1
Around the World Brainteasers - Set of 5$20.00
4.7 stars out of 5 95
New!Punderdome: Wordplay Challenge for Pun Lovers$20.00
5 stars out of 5 1
Back in StockDebatable Party Game$15.00
4.8 stars out of 5 20
Unlock the Cash Viking Chest Puzzle$18.00
not yet rated
Faceted Feline Cat Earrings$86.00
not yet rated
3 Left!Faceted Feline Cat Necklace$86.00
3 stars out of 5 1
Hidden Horror Jump Scare Jigsaw Puzzle$22.00
4.5 stars out of 5 2
Back in StockPrime Suspect Directional Logic Game$13.00
4 stars out of 5 1
New!Sound Explorers: Kids Book of Space Sounds$20.00
not yet rated
Future Bookworm Literary Building Blocks$28.00
4.5 stars out of 5 2
Repurposed Climbing Rope Cozy$25.00
4.8 stars out of 5 6
Zodiac Handmade Garden Stepping Stone$68.00
not yet rated
Italian Spice & Herb Stack$38.00
not yet rated
Phone Jail Escape Room Game$30.00
3.6 stars out of 5 8
New!Storybook Drive Car Freshener Oils - Set of 4$20.00
not yet rated

1 - 95 (of 95 items)

similar categories

unique gifts for book lovers

find unique and fun puzzle gifts for puzzle lovers

gifts for trivia lovers: unique finds and curiosities for quiz enthusiasts

gifts for men who like science

Discover unique gifts for mystery lovers that will keep them guessing and engaged for hours. From intriguing puzzles to clever games, find the perfect present for those who love a good mystery.

What makes us uncommon

forever returns

forever returns

if you don't love it, return it anytime

free shipping

for Uncommon Perks members

independent makers

independent makers

creating innovative designs

better to give

over $3 million donated

founding b-corp

since 2007

no leather, featers, or fur

No leather, feathers, or fur

since our founding in 1999