Paper Gifts for 1st Anniversaries
Celebrate your first year with one-of-a-kind paper gifts that add a personal touch—because standard just won't cut it for your love story!
Intersection of Love - Photo PrintCustomizable $75.00 - $175.00 4.9 stars out of 5star star star star star 1654featured customer reviews
5 stars out of 5star star star star star Perfect Anniversary Gift!
I bought this for my husband for our "Paper" Anniversary (1st) and he absolutely loved it! He thought it was so thoughtful and right away took it to his office to hang it up. He could not get over the quality of it either! I chose the color option and asked for it to be framed and it was perfectly done. Might have to purchase another one that we can hang at home!
- Anita
- Whittier, CA.
Intersection of Love - Photo Print
$75.00 - $175.00 5 stars out of 5star star star star star Perfect 1st Anniversary 'Paper' Gift
For those that follow the traditional anniversary gift giving categories, this is a perfect gift for the 'paper' category of the 1st anniversary. It almost serves as a scrapbook in which you can add pictures, add anecdotes of the anniversary celebration, you add entries about your likes, dislikes, and your goals for the upcoming year. It is really a cool gift to do together and something that will always be a great gift to return to as you fill it out every year. Also highly suggest getting your names added to the cover! A great touch!
- Skipper
- Dania Beach, FL
5 stars out of 5star star star star star Coolest first anniversary gift!
I love this journal. I bought it as an anniversary gift for my husband since the classic first anniversary gift is paper. There are place holders for every year to record what you did to celebrate your anniversary, favorite music/TV/movies/etc. that year, what's happening in the world, and a place for general notes. When we are 100 years old, this will be a neat token to give to our kids or grandkids!
- Kimpossible
- Indiana
$95.00 5 stars out of 5star star star star star gift for 1st anniversary & they loved it
it fit the bill for a first paper anniversary gift. It wasn't over the top and made the couple to think about their first year of married life and why they chose each other.
- Care Bear
- Boca Raton Fl
5 stars out of 5star star star star star Perfect for the 1st "Paper" Anniversary!
I got this for my husband for our first "paper" wedding anniversary, and it was so much fun! Even with no artistic abilities, we were able to create a beautiful map in a short amount of time that we can keep forever. Would recommend to anyone! #sweepstakes
- Lauren
- Dallas, TX
5 stars out of 5star star star star star Unique, sweet and a great gift for the one you love!
I used this as a part of an anniversary gift to commemorate our first year together and all we have yet to do!
- Rachael the PA-C
- Winchester, Virginia
Story of Us Personalized Book of Love
$30.00 - $37.00 Story of Us Personalized Book of LoveCustomizable $30.00 - $37.00 4.7 stars out of 5star star star star star_half 36 The Personalized Anniversary JournalCustomizable $130.00 4.9 stars out of 5star star star star star 212 A Day to Remember Customizable Wall ArtCustomizable $125.00 - $190.00 5 stars out of 5star star star star star 2 Personalized Constellation of LoveCustomizable $125.00 - $195.00 4.7 stars out of 5star star star star star_half 61 New York Times Premium Custom Anniversary BookCustomizable $110.00 - $160.00 4.7 stars out of 5star star star star star_half 93 Intersection of Love Personalized Jigsaw PuzzleCustomizable $45.00 4.7 stars out of 5star star star star star_half 16Paint The National Parks Watercolor Painting Set $45.00 3.6 stars out of 5star star star star_half star_outline 5 Beloved Landscape Custom Collage PrintCustomizable $55.00 - $160.00 4.9 stars out of 5star star star star star 10 Personalized Anniversary Material ArtCustomizable $65.00 4.6 stars out of 5star star star star star_half 8Record Your Own Message: Mix Tape Greetings Card $20.00 1 star out of 5star star_outline star_outline star_outline star_outline 2
Under $50
1 - 34 (of 34 items)
Who are you shopping for?
What are they into at the moment?
Select all that applyShop our suggestions
Celebrate that fabulous first trip around the sun together with gifts that are as unique as your love story! Whether you're shopping for your partner, a best friend, or a couple just starting their happily ever after, our collection of paper gifts is perfect for those who appreciate a thoughtful twist on tradition. These one-of-a-kind treasures bring a personal touch, making them delightful surprises for anyone who’s ready to mark this special occasion in style.
Why paper, you ask? This timeless material symbolizes the delicate beginnings of a new journey—it's all about creativity and possibilities! As you commemorate this milestone anniversary, our paper gifts speak to the idea of building a life together, page by page. Here’s to sharing stories, laughter, and a few unforgettable moments, all wrapped up in a gift that'll make you smile. Cheers to love, laughter, and the adventures that lie ahead!
Shop for anniversary gifts
Which anniversary are you shopping for?
What makes us uncommon

forever returns
if you don't love it, return it anytime

free shipping
for Uncommon Perks members

independent makers
creating innovative designs

better to give
over $3 million donated

founding b-corp
since 2007

No leather, feathers, or fur
since our founding in 1999












































