Item not in your wishlist
Stuffed Cookie Gift Set
Stuffed Cookie Gift Set
Stuffed Cookie Gift Set

Stuffed Cookie Gift Set

Created by Shahira Marei

Soft-baked and generously stuffed, these decadent cookies are made to satisfy every sweet craving.

$60.00

This item is out of stock: Stuffed Cookie Gift Set. We're working hard to get more in, so please leave your email address and we'll let you know if it becomes available.

Handmade

Independent Maker

Made in USA

What Makes Stuffed Cookie Gift Set Uncommon

Bite into one and you'll get it—these cookies are the stuff of dreams. Handmade in New Jersey and generously stuffed with rich, gooey centers, this decadent dozen features a lineup of flavors that hits every craving. From melty hazelnut spread to a PB&J throwback with a twist, each cookie is a soft-baked moment of pure satisfaction. Warm them up or eat them as-is—either way, they’re impossible to forget.

  • Includes 12 generously sized (3-oz.) cookies with gooey centers in 4 irresistible flavors:
    • Chocolate Chip Hazelnut Spread: Classic meets velvety sweet-salty magic.
    • White Chocolate Cookie Butter: Creamy, dreamy, and melt-in-your-mouth good.
    • Peanut Butter & Jelly: A nostalgic twist with peanut butter chips and gooey jelly filling.
    • Double Chocolate Salted Caramel: Rich, fudgy decadence with a buttery caramel surprise.
  • Ready to enjoy—warm them slightly for maximum gooeyness.
  • See nutritional information here.
  • Handmade in New Jersey.
More Info

created by

Shahira Marei

Shahira Marei was born in Egypt and raised in California. When she was 10, she went on a family vacation to her birthplace and was struck by how underserved some communities were. From that experience, Shahira realized her goal was to help others by creating a company centered on its employees. She started her career as an aerospace project manager, but made a major pivot to become a baked-goods entrepreneur. Now, Shahira and her team create a line of delicious treats, like cookie shot cups.

This item includes perishable food, which can only ship via Express

This item ships directly from the maker. If you order today your item will ship no later than 9/21/2026.

Items that are made to order or oversized can't be sent in a Gift Bag. Instead, you can include your Gift Message on the shipment's packing slip. 

At this time, this item cannot be shipped to APO/FPO addresses, P.O. Boxes, or to U.S. Territories including Minor Outlyling Islands. Contact custom@uncommongoods.pro with any questions.

This item is not available to ship outside of the U.S. See International FAQ for more info.

Need to return? Free returns are accepted forever—no time limits. Within 30 days of delivery, refunds to the original payment method will be available. After 30 days, refunds will be processed to a digital gift card. See our return policy for more details.

What are the cookie gift set measurements?

9" L x 7" W x 7" H; Cookies are approx. 2" in Diameter

How do you care for the cookie gift set?

Freshest when enjoyed upon arrival, but can be stored at room temperature for up to 30 days or frozen on arrival for up to 3 months, thaw before serving.

What else should you know about the cookie gift set?

Set of 12 Cookies

What are the ingredients in the cookie gift set?

Peanut Butter & Jelly
Bleached Wheat Flour, Butter, Egg, Brown Sugar, Reese's Peanut Butter Chips, Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter, Modified Cornstarch, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Strawberry Jelly, Granulated White Sugar, Vanilla Extract, Nonfat Dry Milk, Kosher Salt, Baking Soda

Chocolate Chip With Nutella
Bleached Wheat Flour, Butter, Egg, Brown Sugar, Granulated White Sugar, Dark Chocolate, Modified Cornstarch, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Vanilla Extract, Nonfat Dry Milk, Kosher Salt, Baking Soda, Nutella (Sugar, Palm Oil, Hazelnuts, Skim Milk, Cocoa, Soy Lecithin)

White Chocolate Cookie Butter
Bleached Wheat Flour, Brown Sugar, White Chocolate, Biscoff Cookies [Brown Sugar Syrup, Sodium Bicarbonate, Soy Flour, Salt, Cinnamon, Sugar, Soy Lecithin, Citric Acid], Butter, Modified Cornstarch, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Egg, Granulated White Sugar, Vanilla Extract, Nonfat Dry Milk, Kosher Salt, Baking Soda

Double Chocolate Caramel
Bleached Wheat Flour, Butter, Egg, Brown Sugar, Granulated White Sugar, Dark Chocolate, Dulce De Leche, Modified Cornstarch, Cocoa, Vanilla Extract, Nonfat Dry Milk, Kosher Salt, Baking Soda

Contains: Milk, Egg, Wheat, Peanuts, Soy, Hazelnut. MADE IN A FACILITY THAT HANDLES NUTS

Item ID

61692

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

Also by Shahira Marei

similar categories

A handmade gift set stuffed with flavors like Nutella and cookie butter has a way of making any celebration feel more intentional. Wedding season especially calls for that kind of thoughtfulness. Our gifting team points soon-to-be-newlyweds toward our full collection of unique wedding gifts for picks that go well beyond the expected. And when you want to make it truly theirs, our personalized wedding gifts turn a great gesture into something they'll actually keep talking about.

Good gifts are meant to be shared, and the celebration doesn't stop with the couple. Our gifts for the couple cover all the meaningful moments leading up to the big day, and our bridesmaid gifts make sure the people who showed up (in every sense) feel seen too.